Conceptualizing generalizability: New contributions and a reply
MetadataShow full item record
Tsang and Williams offer some good and provocative ideas in their critique of our earlier article on generalizing and generalizability. In this essay we will advance some new ideas by building on those collected in both Tsang and Williams and our original article (Lee and Baskerville 2003). Because IS is a pluralist scientific discipline, one in which both qualitative and quantitative (and both interpretive and positivist) research approaches are valued, “generalize” is unlikely to be a viable term or concept if only one IS research paradigm may lay claim to it and excludes others from using it. Both papers agree on this point, but approach the problem differently. Where we originally generalized generalizability by offering new language, Tsang and Williams conceptualize generalizability by framing it more closely to its older, more statistically oriented form. We agree about the importance of induction and about the classification or taxonomy of different types of induction. We build further in this essay, advancing the ethical questions raised by generalization: A formulation of judgment calls that need to be made when generalizing a theory to a new setting. We further demonstrate how the process of generalizing may actually proceed, based on the common ground between Tsang and Williams and our original article.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
What works in falls prevention in Asia: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trialsHill, Keith; Suttanon, P.; Lin, S.; Tsang, W.; Ashari, Asmidawati; Abd Hamid, T.; Farrier, K.; Burton, E. (2018)BACKGROUND: There is strong research evidence for falls prevention among older people in the community setting, although most is from Western countries. Differences between countries (eg sunlight exposure, diet, environment, ...
Service delivery in rural, remote and regional speech pathology. Part 1: Current approaches; Part 2: The influence of context and philosophyZabiela, Cheraine; Williams, Cori; Leitao, Suze (2007)Part 1 : The aim of this study was to discover the common approaches to service delivery used by speech pathologists in rural, remote and regional Australia, which factors affect the choice of approach, and the theoretical ...
Discordant identification of pediatric severe sepsis by research and clinical definitions in the SPROUT international point prevalence studyWeiss, S.; Fitzgerald, J.; Maffei, F.; Kane, J.; Rodriguez-Nunez, A.; Hsing, D.; Franzon, D.; Kee, S.; Bush, J.; Roy, J.; Thomas, N.; Nadkarni, V.; Fontela, P.; Tucci, M.; Dumistrascu, M.; Skippen, P.; Krahn, G.; Bezares, E.; Puig, G.; Puig-Ramos, A.; Garcia, R.; Villar, M.; Bigham, M.; Polanski, T.; Latifi, S.; Giebner, D.; Anthony, H.; Hume, J.; Galster, A.; Linnerud, L.; Sanders, R.; Hefley, G.; Madden, K.; Thompson, A.; Shein, S.; Gertz, S.; Han, Y.; Williams, Teresa; Hughes-Schalk, A.; Chandler, H.; Orioles, A.; Zielinski, E.; Doucette, A.; Orioles, A.; Zielinski, E.; Doucette, A.; Zebuhr, C.; Wilson, T.; Dimitriades, C.; Ascani, J.; Layburn, S.; Valley, S.; Markowitz, B.; Terry, J.; Morzov, R.; McInnes, A.; McArthur, J.; Woods, K.; Murkowski, K.; Spaeder, M.; Sharron, M.; Wheeler, D.; Beckman, E.; Frank, E.; Howard, K.; Carroll, C.; Nett, S.; Jarvis, D.; Patel, V.; Higgerson, R.; Christie, L.; Typpo, K.; Deschenes, J.; Kirby, A.; Uhl, T.; Rehder, K.; Cheifetz, I.; Wrenn, S.; Kypuros, K.; Ackerman, K.; Maffei, F.; Bloomquist, G.; Rizkalla, N.; Kimura, D.; Shah, S.; Tigges, C.; Su, F.; Barlow, C.; Michelson, K.; Wolfe, K.; Goodman, D.; Campbel, L.; Sorce, L.; Bysani, K.; Monjure, T.; Evans, M.; Totapally, B.; Chegondi, M.; Rodriguez, C.; Frazier, J. (2015)Introduction: Consensus criteria for pediatric severe sepsis have standardized enrollment for research studies. However, the extent to which critically ill children identified by consensus criteria reflect physician ...