Consumer Evaluations of Competing Brands: Perceptual versus Predictive Validity
MetadataShow full item record
This study applies the concepts of consumer predictive and confidence values of information to consumer evaluations of food quality. Examining hypothetical findings from a thought experiment, the study offers advances in cue utilization, predictive validity, and achievement of consumer's perceived quality and actual quality. Separately, metrics for these concepts were applied in a consumer product-quality evaluation study of three brands of peanut butter. Actual quality was operationally defined in terms of Consumers Union ratings of the peanut butter. Using a between-groups, posttest only experimental design, female graduate students (n = 98) tasted and rated one of three peanut butters on the basis of quality and nine product attributes. These informants received no knowledge of brand names or comparative qualities prior to the test. The analysis indicates a nonsignificant correlation between actual quality of the brands and quality as perceived by the informants. The major cues used by informants in making their qualitative judgments (cue utilization) differed from the significant dimensions associated with actual quality (predictive validity). The findings inform the suggestion for consumer training in the process of making accurate quality evaluations.
This is the accepted version of the following article: Woodside, Arch G. 2012. Consumer Evaluations of Competing Brands: Perceptual versus Predictive Validity. Psychology & Marketing. 29 (6): pp. 458-466, which has been published in final form at <a href="http://doi.org/10.1002/mar.20534">http://doi.org/10.1002/mar.20534</a>
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Dickinson, Sonia; Heath, Tara (2006)This paper uses Aaker and Keller's (1990) brand extension model as a theoretical framework to examine the major factors contributing towards positive or negative evaluation of a co-branded offering. The study gained ...
Beverland, M.; Napoli, Julie; Farrelly, F. (2010)Product innovation is vital to ongoing brand equity and has been responsible for revitalizing many brands, including Apple, Dunlop Volley, Mini, and Gucci. While several scholars have noted the relationship between a ...
The role of consumer fanaticism in the acceptance of brand extensions: merchandising in the video games marketYoung, Joshua; Marchegiani, Chris (2010)In the modern marketing environment, many brands seek to expand into new markets while taking advantage of their existing brand name and resources to ensure the success of the venture. However like the introduction of any ...