The use of extrinsic materials by the Courts in the interpretation of taxation legislation
MetadataShow full item record
While the law relating to the use of extrinsic materials, such as second reading speeches and explanatory memoranda, in statutory interpretation appears to be reasonably settled, nonetheless, both the taxpayer and the Commissioner of Taxation have sought to rely on extrinsic material to support a particular interpretation of legislation. The ability to use extrinsic material an have significant implications for the taxpayer or the Commissioner. It is therefore important to understand when it is appropriate to use this material. Significant costs can be incurred by a taxpayer in basing an argument on extrinsic material, only to discover that the courts will not consider such material. This article reviews recent cases to determine to what extent these rules continue to apply and how and when tax practitioners can rely on extrinsic material to support a stance taken against the Commissioner or allow a practitioner to dispute the Commissioner’s use of such material.
First published with The Tax Institute
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Ownership structure, charateristic differences and the size of corporate board of commissioner: The case of Indonesia state-owned enterprisesAstami, Emita; Rusmin, Rusmin; Hartadi, B. (2011)This study scrutinises the association between ownership identity and board size in a unique institutional setting: state-owned enterprises in Indonesia, a country incorporating a two-tier management structure. It ...
Beyond Hijrah (هِجْرَة ): perspectives on resettlement, health and quality of life for Afghan and Kurdish refugees in Christchurch and PerthSulaiman-Hill, Cheryl M. R. (2012)Worldwide, conflict situations and the resultant number of refugees continue to increase, with over 43 million recorded at the end of 2009. Nearly half of those currently under the protection of the United Nations High ...
Gountas, Sandra; Gountas, J. (2008)The desire for fame appears to be an aspiration for many people, which is associatedwith material wealth, social recognition and admiration. Recently, reality TV hasprovided the opportunity for ordinary people to become ...