An Investigation of the Significance of Residual Confounding Effect
MetadataShow full item record
This article is published under the Open Access publishing model and distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/. Please refer to the licence to obtain terms for any further reuse or distribution of this work.
Background: Observational studies are commonly conducted in health research. However, due to their lack of randomization, the estimated associations between the outcome and the exposure can be affected by unmeasured confounding factors. It is important to determine how likely a significant association observed between an outcome variable and a noncausally related exposure may be introduced by residual confounding factors. Methods: A simulation approach is developed based on the sufficient cause model to test the likelihood of significant associations observed between a noncausally related exposure and the outcome. Results: Based on the estimates from all 500 replicates, the association between the exposure and the outcome is found to be significant in 386 (77%) replicates when all confounders (component causes) are controlled for in the model. However, when a subset of real component causes and some noncausal factors are controlled for in the model, the association between exposure and the outcome becomes significant in 487 (97%) replicates. Conclusion: Even when all confounding factors are known and controlled for using conventional multivariate analysis, the observed association between exposure and outcome can still be dominated by residual confounding effects. Therefore, an observed significant association apparently provides limited evidence for a causal relationship.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Musculoskeletal outcomes in children using computers : a model representing the relationships between user correlates, computer exposure and musculoskeletal outcomesHarris, Courtenay (2010)The etiology of musculoskeletal outcomes associated with the use of information technology (IT) has predominately been defined by studies of adults in their work environments. Theories explaining the causation of work ...
Association of pre- and post-natal parental smoking with offspring body mass index: An 8-year follow-up of a birth cohortFlorath, Ines; Kohler, M.; Weck, M.; Brandt, S.; Rothenbacher, D.; Schöttker, B.; Moß, A.; Gottmann, P.; Wabitsch, M.; Brenner, H. (2014)© 2013 The Authors. Pediatric Obesity © 2013 International Association for the Study of Obesity. Summary What is already known about this subject Maternal smoking during pregnancy is associated with offspring overweight, ...
Liang, Wenbin; Zhao, Y.; Lee, Andy (2014)Background: Known and unknown/unmeasured risk factors are the main sources of confounding effects in observational studies and can lead to false observations of elevated protective or hazardous effects. In this study, we ...