It Pays to Violate: How Effective are the Basel Accord Penalties in Encouraging Risk Management?
MetadataShow full item record
The internal models amendment to the Basel Accord allows banks to use internal models to forecast Value-at-risk (VaR) thresholds, which are used to calculate the required capital that banks must hold in reserve as a protection against negative changes in the value of their trading portfolios. As capital reserves lead to an opportunity cost to banks, it is likely that banks could be tempted to use models that underpredict risk and hence lead to low capital charges. To avoid this problem the Basel Accord introduced a backtesting procedure, whereby banks using models that led to excessive violations are penalised through higher capital charges. This paper investigates the performance of five popular volatility models that can be used to forecast VaR thresholds under a variety of distributional assumptions. The results suggest that, within the current constraints and the penalty structure of the Basel Accord, the lowest capital charges arise when using models that lead to excessive violations, thereby suggesting the current penalty structure is not severe enough to encourage adequate risk management. In addition, this paper suggests an alternative penalty structure that is more effective at aligning the interests of banks and regulators.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
It pays to Violate: Model Choice and Critical Value Assumption for Forecasting Value-at-Risk ThresholdsDa Veiga, Bernardo; Chan, Felix; McAleer, M. (2005)The internals models amendment to the Basel Accord allows banks to use internal models to forecast Value-at-Risk (VaR) thresholds which are used to calculate the required capital banks must hold in reserves as a protection ...
Impact of Basel Capital Accord on Bank Behaviour, the impact of Basel Risk based capital requirement (accord I) on Bank performance in the Context of a Small Service-Based island EconomyRamessur, S.; Polodoo, Viren (2015)This paper tests the effect of the Basel Risk Based Capital Requirements (Basel Accord 1) on Mauritian banks' behaviour, using a sample of 9 commercial banks. In the absence of any simultaneity between change in capital ...
Chikolwa, Bwembya C (2008)According to the Reserve Bank of Australia (2006) the increased supply of Commercial Mortgage-Backed Securities (CMBS), with a range of subordination, has broadened the investor base in real estate debt markets and reduced ...