Claims in vapour device (e-cigarette) regulation: A Narrative Policy Framework analysis
MetadataShow full item record
Background: The electronic cigarette or e-cigarette (vapour device) is a consumer product undergoing rapid growth, and governments have been adopting regulations on the sale of the devices and their nicotine liquids. Competing claims about vapour devices have ignited a contentious debate in the public health community. What claims have been taken up in the state arena, and how have they possibly influenced regulatory outcomes? Methods: This study utilized Narrative Policy Framework to analyze the claims made about vapour devices in legislation recommendation reports from Queensland Australia, Canada, and the European Union, and the 2016 deeming rule legislation from the United States, and examined the claims and the regulatory outcomes in these jurisdictions. Results: The vast majority of claims in the policy documents represented vapour devices as a threat: an unsafe product harming the health of vapour device users, a gateway product promoting youth tobacco uptake, and a quasi-tobacco product impeding tobacco control. The opportunity for vapour devices to promote cessation or reduce exposure to toxins was very rarely presented, and these positive claims were not discussed at all in two of the four documents studied. Conclusion: The dominant claims of vapour devices as a public health threat have supported regulations that have limited their potential as a harm reduction strategy. Future policy debates should evaluate the opportunities for vapour devices to decrease the health and social burdens of the tobacco epidemic.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Clearing the air: Protocol for a systematic meta-narrative review on the harms and benefits of e-cigarettes and vapour devicesMacDonald, M.; O'Leary, R.; Stockwell, Tim; Reist, D. (2016)Background: Under the shadow of the tobacco epidemic, the sale and use of e-cigarettes and other vapour devices is increasing dramatically. A contentious debate has risen within public health over the harms and benefits ...
Envisaging a ‘smoke-free’ world: An exploratory study of Philip Morris International’s strategic positioning in AustraliaWolf, Katharina ; Cirillo Woodman, Danielle; Maycock, Bruce; McCausland, Kahlia (2020)The World Health Organization (WHO) has declared tobacco smoking a global health epidemic, citing 8 million deaths and an economic cost of around 1.4 trillion USD per year. Under a UN mandate a global voluntary target was ...
McCausland, Kahlia ; Maycock, Bruce; Leaver, Tama ; Wolf, Katharina ; Freeman, Becky; Jancey, Jonine (2020)Background: As the majority of Twitter content is publicly available, the platform has become a rich data source for public health surveillance, providing insights into emergent phenomena, such as vaping. Although there ...