Drunk and Delirious Defences: Intoxication and Insanity in the Criminal Code (WA)
MetadataShow full item record
In State of Western Australia v Herbert  WASC 101, the question whether s 28(2) of the Criminal Code (WA) (‘Code’) disentitles a concurrently insane and intoxicated accused from availing himself of the insanity defence arose for the first time in this jurisdiction. Critically, the current interpretation of the interaction between the insanity and intoxication defences in ss 27-28 of the Code disentitles an intoxicated accused from availing himself of the insanity defence irrespective of whether his intoxication had any connection to his loss of capacity. This thesis analyses the interaction between the insanity and intoxication defences and suggests how those sections should be interpreted and operate. To that end, it seeks to address how the law should respond to cases such as Herbert where there is an operative mental impairment in circumstances where the accused is also intoxicated, in particular, in circumstances where intoxication is not necessarily connected to a loss of capacity.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Graham, Kathryn; Bernards, S.; Osgood, D.; Abbey, A.; Parks, M.; Flynn, A.; Dumas, T.; Wells, S. (2014)Background: Meeting potential sexual/romantic partners for mutual pleasure is one of the main reasons young adults go to bars. However, not all sexual contacts are positive and consensual, and aggression related to sexual ...
Rockett, I.; Smith, G.; Caine, E.; Kapusta, N.; Hanzlick, R.; Larkin, G.; Naylor, C.; Nolte, K.; Miller, Ted; Putnam, S.; De Leo, D.; Kleinig, J.; Stack, S.; Todd, K.; Fraser, D. (2014)© 2013 American Public Health Association. Suicide and other selfdirected violence deaths are likely grossly underestimated, reflecting inappropriate classification ofmany drug intoxication deaths as accidents or unintentional ...
Graham, K.; Miller, P.; Chikritzhs, Tanya; Bellis, M.; Clapp, J.; Hughes, K.; Toomey, T.; Wells, S. (2014)Intoxication in and around licensed premises continues to be common, despite widespread training in the responsible service of alcohol and laws prohibiting service to intoxicated individuals. However, research suggests ...