To What Extent Should Academic Freedom Allow Academics To Criticise Their Universities?
MetadataShow full item record
Copyright © 2022 Monash University and Monash University Law Review. Reproduced with permission from the publisher.
The recent case of Gerd Schröder -Turk v Murdoch University has thrown up questions in relation to the extent to which an academic is allowed to criticise the university at which they are employed. What freedom, if any, does an academic have to criticise the practices of their Australian university? Are there any limits to this freedom? Are these limits appropriate? These questions in turn raise questions as to the existence and nature of any right that an academic has to exercise academic freedom in Australia and whether and the extent to which this right may provide an academic with more protection to criticise their university employer than they may have otherwise had and whether this may have unintended, detrimental consequences. Does this right to academic freedom allow academics to criticise their institution whether or not they have a reasonable basis for doing so and if so, should this be the case? This article explores these questions with particular reference to the effect of the Model Code for the Protection of Free Speech and Academic Freedom recommended by former High Court of Australia Chief Justice Robert French and proposes some amendments to this Code.
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
Bolt, Susan; Dickie, Laurence (2010)Providing excellent learning experiences for university students often depends on the ability of educators to understand students' learning needs. Formal and informal data collection tools are used to capture the students' ...
The Ridd Case and the model code for the protection of free speech and academic freedom: Wins for academic freedom or losses for university codes of conduct and respectful and courteous behaviour?Guthrie, Robert ; Levine, Pnina (2020)A successful claim for unlawful dismissal and an award of significant damages and pecuniary penalties in favour of Professor Ridd against James Cook University ('JCU') in the Federal Court has attracted attention in the ...
Protecting Academic Freedom in Australian Higher Education Through the Imposition of Restrictions on Investigatory SuspensionLevine, Pnina ; Smith, Leigh (2021)Academic freedom has received considerable recent attention, most notably with the former Chief Justice of the High Court of Australia, Robert French AC, releasing a report containing a Model Code for the Protection of ...