Knowing me, knowing you: What’s the matter with s 21(1)(B) of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth)?
Access Status
Embargo Lift Date
Date
2023Type
Metadata
Show full item recordCitation
Source Title
Faculty
School
Collection
Abstract
The objective test of non-disclosure in s 21(1)(b) of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) remains elusive in its meaning and operation. Despite the time of assessment being prior to entry into a contract of insurance, disputes over an insured’s non-disclosure inevitably arise after a claim is made, when investigations uncover matters an insurer argues were relevant to its decision to accept the risk of a contract of insurance, and the circumstances on which it does. The test in s 21(1)(b) did away with the common law prudent insurer standard of materiality. Despite this, resolution of questions of non-disclosure can be complex exercises in inference drawing, and courts are reticent to give weight to hindsight evidence of insurers. Complex fact scenarios involving the disclosure of opinions and allegations cases have put into question the practical utility of settled principles on the application of the test. Recent cases demonstrate a move towards a broader consideration of circumstances relevant to s 21(1)(b), providing a more flexible construction to resolve conceptual issues that the legislation is otherwise silent on.
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Nanna, Anoo (2011)In Thailand, a universal health insurance coverage policy was implemented in 2001 alongside the reform of public health insurance. Since the reform, Thailand has had three major public health insurance schemes of the ...
-
Kost, A.; Läderach, P.; Fisher, M.; Cook, Simon; Gómez, L. (2012)This paper discusses a methodology to model precipitation indices and premium prices for index-based drought insurance for smallholders. Spatial basis risk, which is borne by the insured, is a problem, especially in ...
-
Gurrib, Muhammad Ikhlaas (2008)This study gives an insight into the behaviour and performance of large speculators and large hedgers in 29 US futures markets. Using a trading determinant model and priced risk factors such as net positions and sentiment ...