Gut content metabarcoding of specialized feeders is not a replacement for environmental DNA assays of seawater in reef environments
Access Status
Authors
Date
2023Type
Metadata
Show full item recordCitation
Source Title
ISSN
Faculty
School
Collection
Abstract
In tropical marine ecosystems, the coral-based diet of benthic-feeding reef fishes provides a window into the composition and health of coral reefs. In this study, for the first time, we compare multi-assay metabarcoding sequences of environmental DNA (eDNA) isolated from seawater and partially digested gut items from an obligate corallivore butterflyfish (Chaetodon lunulatus) resident to coral reef sites in the South China Sea. We specifically tested the proportional and statistical overlap of the different approaches (seawater vs gut content metabarcoding) in characterizing eukaryotic community composition on coral reefs. Based on 18S and ITS2 sequence data, which differed in their taxonomic sensitivity, we found that gut content detections were only partially representative of the eukaryotic communities detected in the seawater based on low levels of taxonomic overlap (3 to 21%) and significant differences between the sampling approaches. Overall, our results indicate that dietary metabarcoding of specialized feeders can be complimentary to, but is no replacement for, more comprehensive environmental DNA assays of reef environments that might include the processing of different substrates (seawater, sediment, plankton) or traditional observational surveys. These molecular assays, in tandem, might be best suited to highly productive but cryptic oceanic environments (kelp forests, seagrass meadows) that contain an abundance of organisms that are often small, epiphytic, symbiotic, or cryptic.
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Dugal, L.; Thomas, L.; Wilkinson, S.P.; Richards, Zoe ; Alexander, J.B.; Adam, Arne A.S. ; Kennington, W.J.; Jarman, Simon ; Ryan, N.M.; Bunce, Michael ; Gilmour, J.P. (2022)The need for efficient and more accurate ways of monitoring threatened ecosystems is becoming increasingly urgent as climate change intensifies. Coral reefs are an example of an ecosystem in crisis, with widespread declines ...
-
West, K.M.; Stat, Michael ; Harvey, Euan ; Skepper, C.L.; Di Battista, Joey ; Richards, Zoe ; Travers, M.J.; Newman, Stephen ; Bunce, Michael (2020)Environmental DNA (eDNA) metabarcoding, a technique for retrieving multispecies DNA from environmental samples, can detect a diverse array of marine species from filtered seawater samples. There is a growing potential to ...
-
DiBattista, Joseph ; Reimer, J.D.; Stat, Michael ; Masucci, G.D.; Biondi, P.; De Brauwer, M.; Bunce, Michael (2019)Background: Effective biodiversity monitoring is fundamental in tracking changes in ecosystems as it relates to commercial, recreational, and conservation interests. Current approaches to survey coral reef ecosystems ...